![]() |
Propeller Head Plaza Technical and scientific discussion of amps, cables and other topics. |
Register / Login
|
In Reply to: Re: Almost agree (surprise!) posted by John Atkinson on May 29, 2006 at 19:26:00:
In 1991, JA wrote an editorial that elicited a response from a reader dismissing Peter Belt's tweaks. In response Richard Lehnart wrote:<< It is important to remember that, in the history of science, theories usually come after the facts to explain otherwise inexplicable events. If Peter Belt's tweaks work, then it is the responsibility of professional audiophiles to first investigate and report that fact (or, at least, that opinion as informed by experience, however subjective), then speculate as to its cause. Rejection of alleged phenomena on purely theoretical grounds — as Mr. Long seems to be doing, regardless of how "common-sense" his position — is indistinguishable from the cant of orthodoxy. >>
Does that mean that Stereophile has now joined the "cant of orthodoxy"?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Words of wisdom from the past? - Charles Hansen 07:49:09 05/30/06 (29)
- Are you confused Mr. Hansen? - bjh 09:04:05 05/30/06 (2)
- Now we know why you and I rarely agree - Charles Hansen 09:21:30 05/30/06 (1)
- Not terribly bright are you? ... a quality concomitant with the need to be always right. nt - bjh 10:24:38 05/30/06 (0)
- Re: Words of wisdom from the past? - May Belt 10:20:50 05/30/06 (4)
- Re: Words of wisdom from the past? - bjh 13:56:27 05/31/06 (2)
- Re: Words of wisdom from the past? - May Belt 14:47:43 05/31/06 (1)
- Thank you. Quite a qualification I must say! - bjh 19:45:55 05/31/06 (0)
- "They think people should know"? But PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO KNOW! - clarkjohnsen 10:38:49 05/31/06 (0)
- Re: Words of wisdom from the past? - John Atkinson 11:15:33 05/30/06 (20)
- Wull, yahbut - Charles Hansen 12:04:36 05/30/06 (19)
- Aaah... - John Atkinson 14:19:59 05/30/06 (18)
- So I suppose that next Stereophile will start publishing Arny Krueger? - Charles Hansen 16:07:23 05/30/06 (3)
- Re: So I suppose that next Stereophile will start publishing Arny Krueger? - John Atkinson 22:25:15 05/31/06 (0)
- I think he'd have to learn to write first. nt - Analog Scott 16:25:04 05/30/06 (1)
- Actually, there is a debate between AK and JA on the Stereophile site. - Pat D 07:16:31 06/01/06 (0)
- As an editor I will agree with John - David W. Robinson 20:15:52 05/30/06 (6)
- Exactly Right - John Atkinson 22:22:09 05/31/06 (1)
- Please note... - Jim Austin 09:28:30 06/01/06 (0)
- As always, the devil is in the details - Charles Hansen 21:02:27 05/30/06 (3)
- Actually, the devil can be many places... - David W. Robinson 23:51:38 05/30/06 (2)
- You would have a different view if you read the article in question. - Charles Hansen 05:44:44 05/31/06 (1)
- One could further add that Austin *ceremoniously* trashed it. - clarkjohnsen 10:30:08 05/31/06 (0)
- The central fact remains... - Jim Austin 04:46:08 05/31/06 (6)
- Re: The central fact remains... - john curl 21:40:16 05/31/06 (1)
- Here's the thread I was referring to over the 'phone. - clarkjohnsen 07:39:37 06/05/06 (0)
- More bullshit appealing to emotions, without a shred of evidence. - Charles Hansen 05:49:22 05/31/06 (1)
- Tune in next week when we'll witness our hero, ... - bjh 07:10:25 05/31/06 (0)
- I must say ... - bjh 08:09:14 05/31/06 (0)
- "...and Charles Hansen gets richer." Now *that* is genuinely crude... and too late to delete! nt - clarkjohnsen 10:34:52 05/31/06 (0)