I won't join the "Is it really Genesis" debate other than to say - meisterkleef

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Genesis reunion rumors - Duilawyer 20:42:18 01/02/07 (39)

This may be in the wrong forum, but it rates the same in my books... - Dman 20:03:35 01/03/07 (2)

I never believe these "It takes 9 months to remaster.." - Duilawyer 22:07:04 01/03/07 (0)

Re: This may be in the wrong forum, but it rates the same in my books... - Squonk 20:44:51 01/03/07 (0)

non-development - Duilawyer 18:19:02 01/03/07 (0)

"...with the other 3." - But why not make it '...and then there were four' by including Steve Hackett? - Audiophilander 21:36:13 01/02/07 (34)

He seems to be a leper, no one wants anything to do with him - Duilawyer 08:47:20 01/03/07 (0)

please don't start another debate about can you leave out and still... - dave c 21:57:10 01/02/07 (32)

there are lots of gray areas, (Styx, New Cars) but that does not mean - Duilawyer 08:50:02 01/03/07 (9)

"There are those who wish to exploit the vaugeires of the concept for financial gain." Errrrrrrrrrrrrrr... - dave c 12:16:21 01/03/07 (8)

The fight between the three remaining Doors is a great - Duilawyer 18:25:18 01/03/07 (7)

I am so happy to hear you were defintely NOT refering to LWR - dave c 20:46:05 01/03/07 (0)

Re: The fight between the three remaining Doors is a great - hitsware 19:55:44 01/03/07 (5)

business in general is amoral - Duilawyer 22:04:25 01/03/07 (0)

the music business is not an area for the discussion of morals - dave c 20:49:57 01/03/07 (3)

Re: the music business is not an area for the discussion of morals - Squonk 00:18:52 01/04/07 (2)

in my experience... - dave c 01:18:04 01/04/07 (1)

99% nt - Duilawyer 18:11:45 01/04/07 (0)

I won't join the "Is it really Genesis" debate other than to say - meisterkleef 07:22:23 01/03/07 (4)

But tens of millions did, they thrived even more after Hackett - Duilawyer 10:50:04 01/03/07 (3)

They thrived because they became a mainstream pop band - jaiva 05:18:29 01/04/07 (2)

Re: They thrived because they became a mainstream pop band - Squonk 10:31:59 01/04/07 (1)

Unlike the early 80's, Gabriel doesn't need the money. Also there is no way he will be able to - jaiva 14:26:04 01/04/07 (0)

Sorry, but without Steve Hackett it just won't be the same Genesis, even fronted by Peter Gabriel. - Audiophilander 23:58:34 01/02/07 (16)

...(other examples)? - hitsware 20:04:50 01/03/07 (0)

I don't believe I hear Hackett on Lamb Lies Down - Duilawyer 08:51:10 01/03/07 (0)

crash helmets, crash helmets1 - dave c 02:28:06 01/03/07 (13)

Good post, but I don't think such distinctions are meaningless. - Audiophilander 13:14:00 01/03/07 (2)

durability or endurability? - dave c 13:41:38 01/03/07 (1)

"I assume that's a typo???" - LOL! It's worse than a typo, it was a total brain fart! :O) - Audiophilander 23:06:26 01/03/07 (0)

Not meaningles, we are the ones who can set the standards - Duilawyer 08:53:30 01/03/07 (9)

I can resist everything except temptation - dave c 12:23:58 01/03/07 (8)

Sure, there are gray areas. That never means there are not - Duilawyer 18:27:04 01/03/07 (0)

Excellent point here, and I agree with your Stones analysis. - Audiophilander 13:40:36 01/03/07 (6)

Two words: Ian Stewart - dave c 13:49:41 01/03/07 (5)

Good point again, but in the group member game it also becomes an image thing. - Audiophilander 23:23:02 01/03/07 (1)

He did play... - dave c 23:56:26 01/03/07 (0)

Care to bring up Fleetwood Mac - LWR 17:44:27 01/03/07 (2)

I was thinking of them while i was out... - dave c 21:01:44 01/03/07 (1)

Re: I was thinking of them while i was out... - Squonk 00:22:05 01/04/07 (0)

Follow Ups

I won't join the "Is it really Genesis" debate other than to say - meisterkleef 07:22:23 01/03/07 (4)

But tens of millions did, they thrived even more after Hackett - Duilawyer 10:50:04 01/03/07 (3)

They thrived because they became a mainstream pop band - jaiva 05:18:29 01/04/07 (2)

Re: They thrived because they became a mainstream pop band - Squonk 10:31:59 01/04/07 (1)

Unlike the early 80's, Gabriel doesn't need the money. Also there is no way he will be able to - jaiva 14:26:04 01/04/07 (0)