In Reply to: Call for comments on tubes vs. transistors posted by theaudiohobby on July 15, 2006 at 21:59:29:
All transistors have junction capacitances which vary with the total applied voltage (signal plus bias). This means the internal capacitances, especially those magnified by the Miller effect, will modulate the open-loop bandwidth with the signal. If the design makes this effect small then transistor amps can sound very clean.All tubes are subject to microphonic modulation of the signal. The internal parts are made of thin, brittle materials and are very lightly supported. Some physical forms are more robust than others, but all tube equipment requires attention to externally-applied mechanical damping measures to avoid loss of detail.
I've heard good sound from tube and solid-state gear where these issues have been addressed in design or by tweaking. I don't know if there is any way to get past the emotions on this topic, but it seems the majority of designs in the marketplace are compromised and some sort of "A is better than B" mindset is likely the reason why.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Different kinds of problems... - Al Sekela 20:31:01 07/16/06 (5)
- The question is cost and power - Bertie_Livingston 16:13:17 07/28/06 (0)
- Re: Different kinds of problems... - Tom Dawson 19:55:13 07/18/06 (1)
- Re: Different kinds of problems... - theaudiohobby 06:35:01 07/19/06 (0)
- Re: Different kinds of problems... - unclestu52 20:20:24 07/17/06 (1)
- Agree, but they are easier to damp. - Al Sekela 11:41:15 07/18/06 (0)