I posted something similar on a less specific forum but am hoping I can get a more useful and informed response from the more educated and experienced `Maggy-ophiles' here...I have trialed MMGs and soon after bought 1.6s which I have been happy with although after ~20 years the itch to upgrade is growing. I enjoy the delicate treble and ethereal quality of the polite precise upper ranges. The detachment of the music from the panels is great although the imaging could be better. I don't miss bass slam as I have another setup that works well for that type of listening. I have the ceiling height and room space to consider the bigger options but my budget limits to pre-owned gear and/or DIY. I listen to streamed stuff via a generic source, so nothing wildly esoteric. I frequent the DIYAudio Pass forum and building amps and preamps is an accompanying process; i.e. this aspect is covered.
Having chewed on this in isolation I'd welcome input from the collective.
The more obvious options appear to be:
A. wait for an opportunity to pick up a set of 3.6R/2.7R or maybe 3.7 panels so as to experience a real ribbon. Or,
B. build a stacked pair of MMG, LRS, 0.7 or maybe even 1.6/1.7 depending upon how it adds up ($ and feet).
C. And occasionally there are Tympanis that come up for sale.your thoughts appreciated,
cheers
Beardy
Edits: 12/01/23
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - Beardy 15:04:02 12/01/23 (64)
- Beardy - Carl G 00:50:32 12/11/23 (7)
- RE: Beardy - Roger Gustavsson 02:12:45 12/11/23 (6)
- volts, currents... lions & tigers etc. - Beardy 14:06:57 12/11/23 (5)
- RE: volts, currents... lions & tigers etc. - andyr 23:44:37 12/11/23 (4)
- RE: volts, currents... lions & tigers etc. - UncleMeat 12:32:28 12/12/23 (3)
- RE: volts, currents... lions & tigers etc. - andyr 14:24:08 12/12/23 (2)
- RE: volts, currents... lions & tigers etc. - UncleMeat 17:35:53 12/12/23 (1)
- RE: Sorry - I've confused contributors. :-(( nt. - andyr 17:44:29 12/12/23 (0)
- RE: Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - panhead 06:07:45 12/05/23 (0)
- RE: Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - ketchup 08:29:44 12/04/23 (44)
- +1. Biamping my 3.6Rs (w/ LL crossover) has been very beneficial. nt. - MWE 15:21:08 12/04/23 (43)
- choices, choices... - Beardy 16:31:44 12/04/23 (42)
- Agree with Andy. In that space,... - MWE 17:45:25 12/04/23 (0)
- RE: "I'm doing due diligence" ... - andyr 17:01:59 12/04/23 (40)
- RE: "I'm doing due diligence" ... - Beardy 17:43:21 12/04/23 (39)
- RE: "goryu posted: I know where there is a set of factory-restored Tympani IVa's!" ... - andyr 18:00:42 12/04/23 (38)
- Tympani 1D versus 3 series - Beardy 20:03:51 12/04/23 (37)
- RE: Tympani 1D versus 3 series - UncleMeat 00:22:51 12/05/23 (35)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - andyr 02:25:47 12/05/23 (34)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - UncleMeat 07:32:55 12/05/23 (33)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - andyr 13:55:17 12/05/23 (32)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - Roger Gustavsson 01:52:22 12/06/23 (27)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - UncleMeat 00:52:04 12/07/23 (26)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - Roger Gustavsson 06:53:39 12/07/23 (25)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - UncleMeat 07:34:29 12/07/23 (24)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - Roger Gustavsson 09:04:02 12/07/23 (23)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - UncleMeat 10:15:06 12/07/23 (22)
- RE: "the push-pull ribbon of the T1-D" ... - Roger Gustavsson 02:12:18 12/08/23 (0)
- Acquired MGIIIA - Beardy 22:42:52 12/07/23 (20)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - UncleMeat 03:01:32 12/08/23 (19)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - Beardy 08:09:44 12/08/23 (18)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - UncleMeat 08:20:22 12/08/23 (17)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - UncleMeat 17:28:50 12/08/23 (16)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - Beardy 20:54:41 12/08/23 (15)
- RE: Acquired MGIIIA - UncleMeat 01:19:06 12/19/23 (0)
- RE: "Ribbons are great" ... - andyr 19:27:06 12/09/23 (13)
- RE: "Ribbons are great" ... - Beardy 23:26:56 12/09/23 (12)
- RE: Excellent ... - andyr 23:28:50 12/09/23 (11)
- RE: Excellent ... - Beardy 09:02:37 12/10/23 (10)
- RE: I would suggest ... - andyr 13:43:56 12/10/23 (0)
- RE: Excellent ... - Roger Gustavsson 09:59:37 12/10/23 (8)
- RE: Excellent ... - UncleMeat 10:38:16 12/10/23 (7)
- RE: Excellent ... - Beardy 14:04:33 12/10/23 (6)
- RE: Excellent ... - UncleMeat 14:20:05 12/10/23 (5)
- RE: Excellent ... - Beardy 14:23:23 12/10/23 (4)
- RE: Excellent ... - andyr 16:14:12 12/11/23 (3)
- RE: Excellent ... - UncleMeat 00:50:07 12/12/23 (2)
- RE: Excellent ... - Roger Gustavsson 01:16:33 12/12/23 (1)
- RE: Excellent ... - UncleMeat 19:07:25 12/12/23 (0)
- Lions and Tigers and Bears! - Beardy 18:40:23 12/05/23 (3)
- RE: Lions and Tigers and Bears! - UncleMeat 23:08:29 12/05/23 (0)
- RE: "Does the push pull tweeter sound different from the QR tweeter in the 1.6?" ... - andyr 18:54:28 12/05/23 (1)
- RE: "Does the push pull tweeter sound different from the QR tweeter in the 1.6?" ... - Beardy 19:25:17 12/05/23 (0)
- aside from bass extension - Beardy 20:18:38 12/04/23 (0)
- RE: Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - goryu 05:57:19 12/04/23 (0)
- RE: Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - josh358 17:02:13 12/03/23 (2)
- RE: "the 2.7R, which has a smaller baffle and shorter ribbon" ... - andyr 02:27:55 12/04/23 (1)
- The new 2.7i DOES have a true ribbon (though 40" vice 60") nt. - MWE 15:17:01 12/04/23 (0)
- RE: Agree with the previous 2 posters ... - andyr 21:26:05 12/02/23 (3)
- True Ribbon... - Beardy 10:36:53 12/03/23 (2)
- RE: True Ribbon... - andyr 12:52:59 12/03/23 (1)
- Thx! - Beardy 13:06:15 12/03/23 (0)
- RE: Thought on potential Maggie upgrade - grantv 19:11:23 12/01/23 (1)
- +11. The TR tweeter is at a different level. nt. - MWE 06:14:29 12/02/23 (0)