 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
178.82.66.174
In Reply to: RE: N core posted by Davey on January 03, 2018 at 15:19:22
No one has to read between the lines with your claims of "straight wire with gain" and if it doesn't sound interesting then it must be that the other amps are adding "excitement" distortion. Hogwash.
You have your credo plastered all over this thread. You are ignoring completely the listening aspect of the whole thing for essentially a view of "if it measures great and sounds boring then there is something wrong with the listener who can't handle the truth".
How is it possible for you to understand someone who thinks a power amplifier should add excitement? I don't understand this even though I think reproduced music should often not sound boring (there are of course some boring recordings...often with way too much compression). Audible distortion, either tonally or temporally, is to be avoided. The key word there is audible. If an amp sounds boring with most of a persons record collection there is likely something wrong temporally that is caused by some aspect of that product's design. Why is that premise so hard for you to accept? Because you worship the static measurements? Read some research into the validity of those measurements by Cheever, Geddes and way back Crowhurst.
You seem to fail to realize that the listener is supreme not the oscilloscope and that low measured distortion does not guarantee good sound or "true" replication of the original signal. There have been several studies showing this can easily be the case. Geddes even found a slightly negative correlation between THD and listener preference. HOW you get rid of distortion matters just as much (or more) than the distortion itself. Your understanding of these things is very superficial.
I think it was Richard Heyser who said " "Perhaps more than any other discipline, audio engineering involves not only purely objective characterization but also subjective interpretations. It is the listening experience, that personal and most private sensation, which is the intended result of our labors in audio engineering. No technical measurement, however glorified with mathematics, can escape that fact."
Follow Ups:
The "straight wire with gain" is an abstract concept. I didn't make it up, but it is (or has been) an objective for some amplifier designers to try and achieve. Certainly there are intangibles, engineering hurdles, etc, etc, that crop up along the process in producing a final (real) product. Whether those intangibles (distortions) produce a more realistic (live, boring, whatever you want to call it) audible result is open for discussion. Nevertheless, the original objective remains.....at least for some designers.
If you think the "straight wire with gain", or my belief that it is the correct objective for power amplifier design is "hogwash", then so be it.
I'm not sure why that amplifier design premise should be so difficult for you to grasp.
It's not just mine.....it's been the design premise of numerous audio amplifier designers through the decades.
Dave.
I am at a loss as to why you think I don't grasp such a basic concept and it is widely known that you didn't come up with it. Whether it is a worthy goal or not in the abstract is not much in debate...all amps should strive for the max linearity...according to the listeners. This is not as subjective as you think as there have reasonable attempts to correlate listener preference with distortion. It turns out to not be what most meter readers expect. The reason being the typical strategy for lowering distortion seems to introduce other issues, the most obvious being reduction of low order harmonics at the expense of making many more, sonically damaging high order harmonics. In other words the PATH to lower distortion is arguably more important than magnitude of the reduction. The impact is highly non-linear.
Linearity according to the scope is not weighted for the impact of those residual distortions on the listeners. Cheever and Geddes both came up with exponential weighting with increasing harmonic order. Once accounted for there is a big change in ranking for sonic "straight wire".
"all amps should strive for the max linearity...according to the listeners."
That's an interesting statement. I hope you're not speaking for most listeners. :)
I believe many listeners don't give a hoot about linearity, or distortion performance, or any other objective evaluation characteristic of power amplifiers.
I think you are, at least somewhat, in that camp as well, yes?
Your treatise on why nearly all audio amplifiers are incorrectly designed establishes your baseline on this topic. Unless you've pulled back on your premise regarding this???
Dave.
They may not care on a technical level but many of them care about it sounding more realistic. Correlating what they find more realistic with measurements IS interesting or at least should be to every audio designer... not just a demonstration of design complexity chops.
I walk the walk, having only SET at home. Linearity within the SET domain though is of interest to me, which is why I go with amps from Aries Cerat. Ultra stable and quiet power supplies and using the most linear tubes and design techniques.
Yes, unfortunately walking the walk to Aries Cerat land is extremely expensive.
Very interesting power amplifier products nonetheless, but not an example of what the audio industry should be producing nowadays. IMHO.
Dave.
Your last sentence is rather odd. Why would AC gear not be what the audio industry should be producing? Because of what? Heat? Weight? Price? The "industry" should produce the best sounding gear possible, IMO. AC represents one company's vision of what it takes to do that.
Cost, of course.
Dave.
Just the last one .... ? :)
You should request a list of acceptable amplifier designs and forward it to AC... BTW you need to give the name of at least one giant killer Class D , best of the best ...
Regards
Edits: 01/05/18 01/05/18
| FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
