![]() |
Digital Drive Upsamplers, DACs, jitter, shakes and analogue withdrawals, this is it. |
Register / Login
|
Model: DAC SE Category: DAC Processors Suggested Retail Price: $1350 Description: NOS R-2R DAC Chip Manufacturer URL: BorderPatrol Model Picture: View
Review by Gary on May 01, 2018 at 15:53:16
IP Address: 96.246.147.126Add Your Review
for the DAC SEAs many of us know, buying equipment can sometimes require a leap of faith. In those situations where listening before buying isn't an option there has to be a willingness to take a chance, even with the best return policy. My only acquaintance with Border Patrol products was what I'd heard at various shows. None of those experiences included this particular product.
For the past few years I've been using an iFi Micro DAC2 and iFi USB 3.0 power conditioner. I've been generally happy with these products. I certainly wasn't looking to replace them anytime soon. I then came across a Steve Guttenberg video review of the Border Patrol DAC. Steve didn't rave and didn't say it was the best he'd ever heard. What I did hear in his review made me curious. This R-2R DAC is non-oversampling, will play files up to 24/96 kHz and uses tube rectification. It will play back Tidal MQA files.
My initial reaction to seeing the specs for this unit was that there was no way I was going to put a DAC limited to 24/96 in my system. Why was I even considering this product? After some thought the answer came to me: I cannot reliably and consistently tell the difference between hi-res and redbook files. I don't think that has anything to do with equipment choices. I think it has everything to do with my hearing ability, or the lack thereof. I'm not saying there's no audible difference. I'm saying that most of the time I can't hear it. With that said I then thought that perhaps the Border Patrol unit might be something I'd like. I was intrigued by the idea of tube rectification. I'm not aware of any other audio manufacturer who does that in a DAC.
Then, there's the issue of warmth. I wanted a DAC that would narrow the gap between my preferred format, vinyl, and digital playback. The iFi equipment I have does that to an extent, but the Border Patrol DAC SE is much better in that regard. For me, there's a natural warmth and flow to the music played back through this unit. It isn't analog but at least we're now in the same neighborhood. It does this without sounding tubby or soft. I hear as much detail as I can without encountering any sharp corners. Is it accurate? Who the hell knows? At my age I'm far less interested in accuracy than I am in tone. I want equipment that doesn't wear me out. I want a presentation that invites me in and encourages me to stay for a while. I wanted a DAC that made it easier for me to wade through the choices on Tidal without thinking about how long I've been listening. For some reason, and this is my fault not iFi's, prior to the Border Patrol DAC I'd find myself often distracted by resolution questions. It got even worse after I added HQ Player by Signalyst. The sound was wonderful but I did too much clicking and not enough listening. I wanted something simpler and even better sounding. I found that in the Border Patrol DAC SE.
This thing took about three to four days to break-in. This is embarrassing but I'll admit it - The first time I listened I did so without the tube rectification turned on. I didn't even realize until I looked at the tube and could see it was powered down. I hadn't held the power button on long enough. It sounds better with tube rectification. I'll also admit to some doubts during the first twenty-four hours of listening. It sounded OK but not what I'd hoped for. It took a little more time but after that there was no doubt. I wasn't returning it. What I was hearing was definitely an improvement. The sound was open, warm and involving. I moved the iFi gear to my main desktop machine so I could still indulge any curiosity I have regarding hi-res. I know it's still early days but this device is something special.
Obviously this unit isn't going to work for anyone wanting very hi-res play back. It's retro and for me it's wonderful. I've come to enjoy streaming playback almost as much as I do vinyl. For me, that's a very welcome outcome.
Product Weakness: I don't know. I haven't found any yet. Product Strengths: Natural and engaging playback. Simplicity of use. Associated Equipment for this Review:
Amplifier: Cary Audio SA200.2 Preamplifier (or None if Integrated): Cary SLP 98P Sources (CDP/Turntable): Marantz 8003, VPI Aries Black Knight Speakers: JM Reynaud Offrande Cables/Interconnects: Coincident Music Used (Genre/Selections): Jazz Room Size (LxWxH): 25 x 14 x 10 Time Period/Length of Audition: Two weeks Type of Audition/Review: Product Owner
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Gary 15:53:16 05/01/18 (42)
- What about the bass? - Emil 10:43:04 05/10/18 (0)
- A Politically Motivated DAC GREAT - Dynobot 16:12:06 05/03/18 (15)
- There are good people on both sides of this issue. * - Billy Wonka 08:24:57 05/08/18 (1)
- RE: There are good people on both sides of this issue. * - Dynobot 19:21:35 05/08/18 (0)
- A "Far Out" DAC without Political Motivation - Thorsten 19:43:40 05/03/18 (10)
- Tongue and Cheek - Dynobot 20:15:34 05/03/18 (9)
- In. - oldmkvi 09:53:03 05/04/18 (7)
- I'm Offended by You Correcting ME!!!!!!!! - Dynobot 14:11:05 05/04/18 (5)
- RE: I'm Offended by You Correcting ME!!!!!!!! - sideliner 18:11:29 05/05/18 (4)
- No, that was my A-Bomb. As GI Joe said: - oldmkvi 08:23:36 05/06/18 (3)
- LOL...Seeee its hard to remember....and/in nt - Dynobot 09:08:29 05/06/18 (2)
- That was by way of apology. I think you accepted it... - oldmkvi 19:22:06 05/06/18 (1)
- No Worries - Dynobot 14:59:55 05/07/18 (0)
- Akin to "Tow the Line" - rickmcinnis@dogwoodfabrics.com 12:29:05 05/04/18 (0)
- RE: Tongue and Cheek - Gary 08:31:46 05/04/18 (0)
- RE: A Politically Motivated DAC GREAT - Gary 16:26:53 05/03/18 (1)
- RE: A Politically Motivated DAC GREAT - Dynobot 16:44:28 05/03/18 (0)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Thorsten 21:24:58 05/02/18 (11)
- RE: Non-OS with Micro iDSD BL - fred76 18:53:38 05/12/18 (2)
- RE: Non-OS with Micro iDSD BL - Thorsten 01:12:05 05/13/18 (1)
- RE: Thanks T! (nt) - fred76 09:56:09 05/13/18 (0)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Gary 08:35:44 05/03/18 (2)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Thorsten 18:57:50 05/03/18 (1)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Gary 11:06:47 05/04/18 (0)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Mr_Steady 06:26:45 05/03/18 (4)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Thorsten 04:48:51 05/04/18 (1)
- RE: REVIEW: BorderPatrol DAC SE DAC Processors - Mr_Steady 05:43:15 05/04/18 (0)
- All opamps require GNFB regardless of what is inside. - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 20:26:34 05/03/18 (1)
- RE: All opamps require GNFB regardless of what is inside. - Mr_Steady 05:35:17 05/04/18 (0)
- Very informative, well written review--NT - lancelot 09:09:27 05/02/18 (1)
- RE: Very informative, well written review--NT - Gary 11:11:11 05/02/18 (0)
- BorderPatrol??? Really? Does it have Brick WALL Filtering? - oldmkvi 07:30:44 05/02/18 (10)
- If I'm selecting equipment for "edgy" names... - Daverz 08:10:57 05/02/18 (1)
- RE: If I'm selecting equipment for "edgy" names... - Crazy Dave 08:36:50 05/02/18 (0)
- RE: BorderPatrol??? Really? Does it have Brick WALL Filtering? - Gary 08:09:10 05/02/18 (0)
- :-) :-) :-) - PAR 07:32:56 05/02/18 (6)
- This stuff writes itself! nt - oldmkvi 08:45:07 05/02/18 (5)
- RE: New and improved! Now with "National Guard" power supply protection nt - bean 08:49:17 05/02/18 (4)
- Next! Keep'em coming, we're on a Roll here... nt - oldmkvi 10:38:40 05/02/18 (3)
- Bad news it costs $130k. Good news Michael Cohen bought me one! (nt) - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 20:33:06 05/03/18 (2)
- Wow, that's as much as a Date with Stormy D! nt - oldmkvi 09:54:45 05/04/18 (1)
- RE: just put a blonde wig on the DAC, and play some electronic dance music nt - bean 11:15:06 05/04/18 (0)