RE: missed the point completely

Posted by Duster (M) on July 28, 2018 at 11:33:17

In Reply to: missed the point completely posted by madisonears on July 27, 2018 at 18:08:27:

I never claimed that the reason why the 50V Nichicon FW sounds clearly superior to the 16V Panasonic FC is due to a higher voltage rating. If you would stop trying to find fault and denigrate my credibility as a poster in AA, you might have a clearer perspective of things I might say. Otherwise, I have no desire to have discussions with you other than defending myself when you misrepresent my posts and act like an enemy. There is no rule in AA forum politics that requires interaction with those who act as bullies, trolls, or enemies.

I wrote as the OP of this thread:

"I'd like to make sure that a capacitor upgrade involving the same microfarad value but with a higher voltage rating is suitable for this particular circuit design"

Some folks clearly opined that it is okay for the particular circuit, while Lew posted the notion of choosing an electrolytic capacitor with a voltage rating that's closest to the operating voltage, unlike the notion of choosing a substantially larger rated voltage film capacitor. So I understand the premise. The only matter that I had issue with was the statement that claims the 50V Nichicon FW would not be a worthwhile tweak vs. the stock 16V Panasonic FC for the application.

Lew's opinion of:

"This is contrary to the theory as it applies to film type capacitors. So, I doubt you'll be better off with this tweak."

My response was about not being better off with this tweak:

"From a sonic POV, the 50V Nichicon FW sounds clearly superior to the 16V Panasonic FC for this application, Lew."

It's really quite easy to understand what I've said within this thread if a reader has an open mind.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - Duster 15:36:24 07/16/18 (36)

RE: Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - gordguide 00:51:13 10/23/18 (0)

Voltage rating and electrolytic capacitors - Lew 22:24:11 07/22/18 (12)

RE: Voltage rating and electrolytic capacitors - Duster 15:09:40 07/23/18 (11)

What does this prove? - madisonears 19:21:33 07/26/18 (7)

RE: What does this prove? - Duster 21:21:22 07/26/18 (6)

missed the point completely - madisonears 18:08:27 07/27/18 (5)

What I said also - Lew 08:45:32 07/30/18 (3)

RE: What I said also - Duster 11:04:18 07/30/18 (2)

RE: What I said also - Lew 08:45:27 08/02/18 (1)

RE: What I said also - Duster 15:14:49 08/03/18 (0)

RE: missed the point completely - Duster 11:33:17 07/28/18 (0)

If you say so,... - Lew 20:31:14 07/24/18 (2)

RE: If you say so,... - KanedaK 00:34:41 07/27/18 (0)

RE: If you say so,... - Duster 14:43:41 07/26/18 (0)

Hope they fit - madisonears 19:06:42 07/16/18 (17)

They fit fine. - Duster 19:53:56 07/16/18 (16)

Nichicon FW - Salectric 05:09:34 07/23/18 (10)

" In the bias supply of my push-pull amps" - 1973shovel 06:11:05 07/23/18 (9)

RE: " In the bias supply of my push-pull amps" - Salectric 07:36:37 07/23/18 (8)

1000 uF? - 1973shovel 08:18:02 07/23/18 (7)

RE: 1000 uF? - Salectric 08:38:58 07/23/18 (6)

Ahh, here it is - 1973shovel 10:11:39 07/23/18 (5)

RE: Ahh, here it is - Salectric 11:09:10 07/23/18 (4)

RE: Ahh, here it is - 1973shovel 12:15:30 07/23/18 (3)

RE: Ahh, here it is - Salectric 12:54:37 07/23/18 (2)

"Your photo brings back memories for sure" - 1973shovel 13:40:35 07/23/18 (1)

RE: "Your photo brings back memories for sure" - Salectric 14:21:37 07/23/18 (0)

RE: They fit fine. - KanedaK 00:08:40 07/21/18 (4)

From the late Al Sekela... - 1973shovel 06:52:03 07/21/18 (2)

RE: From the late Al Sekela... - Duster 10:13:28 07/22/18 (1)

2004 - 1973shovel 04:56:04 07/23/18 (0)

RE: They fit fine. - Duster 03:52:15 07/21/18 (0)

RE: Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - fastcat 16:55:00 07/16/18 (3)

RE: Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - Duster 17:20:54 07/16/18 (2)

RE: Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - fastcat 18:23:18 07/16/18 (1)

RE: Capacitor upgrade with higher voltage rating. - Duster 18:38:34 07/16/18 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: missed the point completely - Duster 11:33:17 07/28/18 (0)

RE: missed the point completely

Post a Message!