|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
81.19.57.162
In Reply to: DVD-Audio Authoring is Stupid posted by Charles Hansen on November 14, 2005 at 16:23:33:
Charles,That's quite interesting what you report, and I'm sure your information will be useful to owners of that machine (or prospective owners) who are reading this. (i.e. it is possible to play any group and track on a DVD-A with the C-5xe.)
By the way, regarding the LPCM stereo tracks which appear as if they are duplicated on Groups 3 and 4, what I think is the case, is that these are just ‘references’ to the same underlying data. I don’t think that Dr. Mark Waldrep could have made so many duplicates of uncompressed LPCM and have them all fit onto one single layer DVD-5, along with the MLP 5.1, Dolby 5.1 AND DTS 5.1 content! ;-).
And when the player is set to DVD-Video mode, likewise, I think it’s still just referencing the one underlying LPCM data track, i.e. I don't think Video_TS is duplicating it.
Follow Ups:
and list the contents of AUDIO_TS and VIDEO_TS directory? Can you also run DVD Decryptter/DVDAExplorer and let me know the structure of the AUDIO_TS and VIDEO_TS content?I'm very interested to know, because i haven't been able to link into VIDEO_TS from the DVD-Audio structure. Wavelab doesn't support it, and the version of Chrome I have does an "import" rather than "link" (ie., it copies the stems and duplicates the content).
I noticed Neil Wilkes is having similar issues since he's posted a message about this in the Wavelab support forum.
. . . at the structure of the AIX Scarlatti disk . . . and e-mailed screenshots of the Audio_TS & Video_TS directories to you. I'm sure you can make more sense of them than I can.b.t.w. I also tried to look at them in the tools you mentioned, but the DVDA tool only shows the MLP files in Audio_TS; while the other DVD-V tool won't read anything at all in Audio_TS. So neither are any help when looking for LPCM files which may be duplicated in Audio_TS.
You can post here or e-mail me what your findings are . . .
You can link DVD-Video and DVD-Audio content by using multiple VTS sets and using a VGM menu to link them. The basis is to author one project first (DVD-Video usually), compile it, then import it with a link from the DVD-Audio project. You need software that supports this though.
*** You need software that supports this though. ***That's the real issue. I haven't come across documented evidence of an authoring tool that supports it. I've also yet to see hard evidence of an actual commercial disc that implements linking (as opposed to duplicated content).
I understand there's some fairly severe restrictions that constrain whether the link will work or not.
Neil Wilkes said the current version of Chrome should support it, but I asked him to do a test DVD to demonstrate that it works and so far haven't heard from him.
DVDLab Pro supports the importing of pre-compiled VTS content, but that would mean you'd have to author the DVD-Audio first, then the DVD-Video so that would prevent AUDIO_TS to VIDEO_TS linking, you could only do VIDEO_TS to AUDIO_TS.> I've also yet to see hard evidence of an actual commercial disc that implements linking (as opposed to duplicated content). <
There are a few, but I forget which. I seem to remember there were some discs with 96kHz PCM that was available to DVD-Video players that was actually in the AUDIO_TS folder so that it couldn't be ripped (prior to the DVD-A hacks). That at least cuts down on disc space to a certain degree, the two-channel content can be shared.
> > "There are a few, but I forget which. I seem to remember there were some discs with 96kHz PCM that was available to DVD-Video players that was actually in the AUDIO_TS folder ..."discs from the Hi-Res Music catalog.
DVDLab (Pro) is a DVD-Video authoring tool - it does not understand the AUDIO_TS structure. Try it yourself - you cannot import any DVD-Audio content, not even unprotected ones.*** I seem to remember there were some discs with 96kHz PCM that was available to DVD-Video players that was actually in the AUDIO_TS folder so that it couldn't be ripped ***
I don't think this is possible, but happy to be corrected on this. The DVD-Video spec predates DVD-Audio, so there is no provision to link into AUDIO_TS content - and DVD-Video players do not contain the logic to parse AUDIO_TS.
All the discs that I've encountered so far with LPCM content on both DVD-Video and DVD-Audio turned out to be duplicates rather than linked content.
You can just import an entire DVD structure with any tool, only specific VTS sets. The key is to do that when authoring the DVD-A content. You can then link to it in DVDLab pro by writing your own links (just trying to drop an AUDIO_TS set into the program will not work, of course).
no, AUDIO_TS has a *different* structure - doesn't use VTS or VOB, therefore not recognisable by DVD-Video authoring tools.
Hi Christine,I'll see what I can do. I do have numerous AIX titles -- DVD-5s -- which use the same authoring, including MLP, DTS, Dolby, and LPCM mixes like the Stravinsky disc which Charles Hanson has.
A while back, I did download the DVD-Decryptor stuff out of curiosity, and I'll see if I've still got them on my hard drive somewhere.
b.t.w. I could be wrong about these discs not duplicating the LPCM in Audio_TS and Video_TS, I did ask Mark a while back, but I never got a straight answer!
However, I still find it hard to believe they could do that from a space standpoint.
Thanks. look forward to your observations.*** However, I still find it hard to believe they could do that from a space standpoint. ***
You can probably do the calculation yourself. One DVD-5 can contain around 6 uncompressed CDs. LPCM96/24 takes slightly over twice the data storage, but if you compress it using MLP then it takes around the same space as 1 CD. So in theory you can fit about 6 MLP 96/24 2.0 tracks on one DVD-5.
MLP 96/24 5.1 takes about 1.5 * uncompressed CD.
I really would like to see solid evidence of a DVD-Audio with proper linking to VIDEO_TS since all the discs that I have seen so far contain duplicated content rather than linking. Maybe that's a limitation of current generation authoring tools, I am not sure.
It's possible that this disc is a dual-layer DVD-9. When I was looking at the various Groups, there were some navigational changes that took a longer time than others, suggesting that a layer change was involved.
-- as are all the other "Bucharest Session" AIX DVDAs -- it would be recognisable as a DVD-9 if it had two-concentric barcode rings. If, however, it's a DVD-5, then just one barcode ring at the center ring is usually present. (At least with the discs I've seen to date.)Also, double-layered sides are sometimes gold-colored, while single-layered sides are silver-colored, like a CD.
.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: