|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: Re: I didnt know the hi rez flip disk even started, aside from the seattle-boston experiment... posted by patrickU on April 07, 2004 at 10:12:56:
. . . was your article written/sourced by the critic "Barry Fox", by any chance?B.T.W. . . . Dieter Dirks was always 'disputing'. He reckons he owns the ‘rights’. However, he apparently developed it while working for Warner, and Warner still has rights to make it for its own purposes (would seem logical).
Also, disk thickness has frequently been cited. The max allowable thickness for CD/DVD media is 1.5mm, and the DualDisc's max thickness is about 1.45mm. So it should be OK (providing they can maintain the tight tolerances during manufacture -- which they reckon they can.
Follow Ups:
Well old for you, but not for me!
And yes it is Barry Fox / May 2004. But why wanting to discredite him?
One another test of the Sony SCD-XA9000ES by Paul Miller ( good guy for digital ) against DVD-A...Well read it for yourself!
That would be to controversial here....
No, I do not know the results in advance.
No, I do not have a favorite.
No, I am not trying to start a flame war.
No, I am not on the DVD-A team.
No, I am not on the "Kill SACD" team.
No, I am not on any team.I have no financial or vested interest in either format.
And , I have NO " particuliar or peculiar,... " relation with Chris.
Thats all.....
.
nt
I'm not discrediting Barry Fox. He is a "critic". That's his job. It's funny, though, how all the anti-DualDisc stuff seems to come from him. (At least, that's my observation over the last few months). It's also funny how he’s never seemed to criticize SACD, and often there’s a SACD ‘plug’ in his articles on DualDisc. One does therefore wonder if there is a thinly-veiled agenda here?
recordings sound nearly as good on my Esoteric DV-50 as on their DVD-A counterparts. So SACD may outlive the death of DSD.
And knows of some DAD´s who sounds better than a lot of SACD and as fars I knows as DVD-A...
It depends of the capability of the guys on the other side, mostly.
pull in that other line our you may get "hooked" for trolling without a license! Who really cares what is written in the press? Enjoy your music and forget the rhetoric. By the way, do you read magazines while you listen or do you just read magazines?
I like to fish in trouble waters. Well if you really wants to know...Both.
As I always enjoy music...Hehe...
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: