In Reply to: DVD-Music... posted by Wellfed on May 3, 2003 at 09:20:02:
That's precisely what DVD-Audio is supposed to be: DVD for audio, without the need for video content required in the DVD specs. Perhaps they could rename it DVD-M, but I doubt it.The stereo tracks are not an obligation in the DVD-A specs, and it is left to the author to decide what should be included on a DVD-A disc. The specs specify the need for stereo downmixing compatibility for the MCH tracks.
Having said that, Silverline is the only company currently not releasing titles with a stereo track. All other publishers include a "true" stereo version in their titles: in the DVD-A section (PCM 24/96) and on the DVD-V section (DD 2.0). A number of publishers are using the PCM 24/96 for both the DVD-A and the DVD-V section.
I do not have the Aaron Neville titles, so I don't know if they include a stereo section. They should.
As I'm sure you know, stereo tracks authored in a DVD-A can include much higher resolution (24/192), although there are still very few titles available. When you try one of those, you will notice the difference. This is the highest resolution for audio available today.
You should definitely investigate other labels in addition to Silverline.
There's a good list of reference recordings on www.dvd-a.dkBest
Eric
PS: You're right, all things considered, it's a mess :)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Well, wellfred... - Eric LeRouge 12:40:07 05/03/03 (12)
- Thanks Eric...Would I be better off with Redbook titles... - Wellfed 17:04:15 05/03/03 (1)
- Yes. The downmixing is a horrible compromise. nt - Duilawyer 07:54:42 05/04/03 (0)
- Do you know... - ducati 15:17:24 05/03/03 (8)
- Re: Do you know... - Eric LeRouge 07:40:31 05/04/03 (5)
- I have two DVD-V players that output 24/96 - ducati 10:07:07 05/04/03 (2)
- Did you check this is the digital out? - Eric LeRouge 12:58:22 05/04/03 (1)
- Yep :) - ducati 14:33:27 05/04/03 (0)
- Re: Do you know... - NotMe 09:55:11 05/04/03 (1)
- Thanks, good info... - ducati 10:08:19 05/04/03 (0)
- Re: Do you know... - HighEndWire 16:03:40 05/03/03 (1)
- Thanks!! - ducati 10:03:59 05/04/03 (0)
- Re: Well, wellfred... - NotMe 13:32:30 05/03/03 (0)