I agree - Joe Murphy Jr - DVD-Audiobahn

I agree

Posted by Joe Murphy Jr (A) on April 15, 2003 at 08:08:16

In Reply to: Re: John, it gets stranger still... posted by Dave Kingsland on April 14, 2003 at 16:57:26:

While I think that most will agree that Telarc puts out consistent and often amazing recordings, I agree with Dave's assesment of that "redirected" bass via the producer -- Telarc -- and the fact that it shouldn't be done this way. Let the end user have the final say, as he/she is the only one who knows what capabilities exist in his/her playback system.

This is just one more problem that needs to be addressed by the recording community and the product manufacturers. Is it really that hard for these two groups to get together and discuss what process will get the most from the new high resolution formats?

As for a "height" channel for channel #6 (the .1), I haven't heard this implemented, so I can't say for sure if this is a good idea vs a discrete rear surround channel a la DTS-ES 6.1 Discrete (for movies). I can see a "height" channel for "effects" in a movie, but I'd think that music is another matter (at least until I've heard it, but I'm not a fan of multichannel for music as it is, so...). Maybe we need a discrete 7.1 system so that we can also have a height channel for movies? Anyone for DTS-ES 7.1 Discrete? It is an option for the codec...

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - LFE, DVD-A and SACD? - Jim Pearce 11:39:09 04/14/03 (21)

Re: LFE, DVD-A and SACD? - John Kotches 12:15:25 04/14/03 (20)

John, it gets stranger still... - Jim Pearce 12:59:37 04/14/03 (19)

I have a question regarding this Denon filter... - MT 15:28:54 04/14/03 (1)

Re: I have a question regarding this Denon filter... - Martin 07:08:30 04/22/03 (0)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - John Kotches 13:50:14 04/14/03 (16)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - Kal Rubinson 15:02:07 04/14/03 (15)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - John Kotches 20:50:11 04/14/03 (8)

John, take a look at Michael Bishop's comments.... - Jim Pearce 11:29:29 04/16/03 (0)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - Kal Rubinson 18:44:18 04/15/03 (6)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - John Kotches 20:37:52 04/15/03 (5)

Not necessarily. - Jim Pearce 12:00:18 04/16/03 (2)

Re: Not necessarily. - John Kotches 13:00:51 04/16/03 (1)

Agreed, we're way off track. - Jim Pearce 13:28:25 04/16/03 (0)

Ah... - Kal Rubinson 08:02:31 04/16/03 (1)

Re: Ah... - John Kotches 09:03:10 04/16/03 (0)

Perhaps I wasn't clear... - Jim Pearce 20:16:36 04/14/03 (2)

Re: Perhaps I wasn't clear... - Dave Kingsland 03:43:28 04/15/03 (1)

You're right, Dave. - Jim Pearce 06:38:13 04/15/03 (0)

Re: John, it gets stranger still... - Dave Kingsland 16:57:26 04/14/03 (2)

I agree - Joe Murphy Jr 08:08:16 04/15/03 (1)

I disagree. - Jim Pearce 08:31:40 04/15/03 (0)

Follow Ups

I agree - Joe Murphy Jr 08:08:16 04/15/03 (1)

I disagree. - Jim Pearce 08:31:40 04/15/03 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.