So why does soundstage collapse on CD ? - SnaggS

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Beatles on DVD-A : Confirmed in Press - SnaggS 20:56:30 04/05/03 (62)

The question is: when? - Frank 11:58:58 04/07/03 (0)

Here's an Abby Road,( hint, hint) link - danbry39 10:35:33 04/06/03 (3)

Yes, read that, but it didn't actually say "Beatles" [nt} - SnaggS 17:51:56 04/06/03 (1)

Do a search on 'klaatu' on google ;) <nt> - Frank 10:56:18 04/07/03 (0)

... and the follow up - TA 17:15:54 04/06/03 (0)

a link? - Denis Powell 04:39:05 04/06/03 (56)

As commanded....... - SnaggS 06:21:10 04/06/03 (55)

That's like five months old, LOL.....nt - Chris Garrett 09:28:47 04/06/03 (54)

Oh, first time I saw it......... <blush> {nt} - SnaggS 17:50:31 04/06/03 (0)

Yes, it's five months old. However, it's scary news, isn't it? Goes against the Hi-Rez agenda. - 9fold 14:46:35 04/06/03 (2)

Insurance money run out? - Chris Garrett 19:34:19 04/06/03 (1)

But maybe Sony's money will run out ! :) {n.t.} - Martin says 07:41:13 04/07/03 (0)

still Chris if DVD-Audio actually released the entire Beatles catalog with NO SACD releases of the - Teresa 13:20:02 04/06/03 (49)

True, I'd stick to Vinyl myself if DVD-A is the choice. {nt} - SnaggS 17:54:21 04/06/03 (0)

No way, Teresa - Eric LeRouge 15:25:10 04/06/03 (8)

I find it hilarious.. - rick5 18:03:11 04/06/03 (7)

Sadly, the same can be said for the DVD-A supporters ... - Jack Seaton 06:49:58 04/07/03 (0)

Nope, just waiting for the Beatles to be released on SACD......... - Chris Garrett 19:42:06 04/06/03 (3)

Chris, maybe you should refrain - Eric LeRouge 02:50:07 04/07/03 (2)

Actually, at this point........... - Chris Garrett 17:36:58 04/07/03 (1)

Nothing will "shake out" - Eric LeRouge 04:41:31 04/08/03 (0)

For your information I do still listen to 24 Bit 96kHz DADs from Classic, Chesky and Hi Res Music - Teresa 18:32:44 04/06/03 (1)

Audio DVD (DAD) was a good format - Eric LeRouge 02:37:56 04/07/03 (0)

Re: still Chris if DVD-Audio actually released the entire Beatles catalog with NO SACD releases of t - Jesper 14:14:07 04/06/03 (38)

Absolutely. People here say SACD is better like it's fact. Duh. (nt) - 9fold 14:44:47 04/06/03 (37)

It is a fact SACD is better, it's all in the listening. However we live in a Capitalist world and - Teresa 17:10:27 04/06/03 (36)

"fact"? no such thing, just opinions. Your credibility just went out the door - Jerry Golding 09:15:54 04/07/03 (1)

My credibility just went out the door because I dared to suggest that Money is more important to the - Teresa 18:13:37 04/07/03 (0)

Again, more BS from you. - EnuffzEnuff 18:10:43 04/06/03 (28)

Not better sounding but more musical, ANYONE can hear the difference, even you! Just listen in - Teresa 18:45:19 04/06/03 (27)

Re: Not better sounding but more musical, ANYONE can hear the difference, even you! Just listen in - RdH 08:11:57 04/07/03 (5)

When the cat is away, the mice will play... - SnaggS 18:32:48 04/07/03 (1)

Re: When the cat is away, the mice will play... - RdH 20:29:03 04/07/03 (0)

funny that "distortion introduced via DSD" is the same "distortion" I hear with live music or vinyl - Teresa 18:20:17 04/07/03 (2)

Teresa, unless you do a serious test, you have no way of saying this - Eric LeRouge 04:32:52 04/08/03 (0)

Re: funny that "distortion introduced via DSD" is the same "distortion" I hear with live music or vi - RdH 20:27:17 04/07/03 (0)

"Science cannot explain music, period!" -- You must be ignorant as well as stupid, Teresa. {n.t.} - Martin says 01:53:54 04/07/03 (3)

correct Martin "Science cannot explain music, period!" wake up Martin and use your ears! (nt) - Teresa 18:23:01 04/07/03 (2)

Teresa -- trying to twist my argument, just makes you look even more ridiculous. {n.t} - Martin says 02:25:19 04/08/03 (1)

But you see kind Martin I do not believe in Science when Music is concerned, I trust only my ears! - Teresa 18:33:52 04/08/03 (0)

Please prove your claims. - EnuffzEnuff 20:18:34 04/06/03 (15)

nothing to prove: Music is an ART is cannot be measured it can only be enjoyed. - Teresa 22:15:45 04/06/03 (0)

Subjective claims cannot really be proven... - oscar 20:45:36 04/06/03 (13)

Re: Subjective claims cannot really be proven... - Martin says 02:31:32 04/07/03 (12)

eloquent and absurd - tunenut 10:58:24 04/07/03 (3)

Eloquent and succinct . . . - Martin says 03:13:08 04/08/03 (1)

yes I know.. - tunenut 09:36:49 04/08/03 (0)

agreed go to a live acoustic concert, come home listen to an Audiophile LP on a decent Vinyl rig - Teresa 18:29:57 04/07/03 (0)

So why does soundstage collapse on CD ? - SnaggS 06:54:04 04/07/03 (6)

Not really... - MCH 08:40:58 04/07/03 (4)

Soundstaging -- speakers & CD source . . . - Martin says 02:36:09 04/08/03 (0)

MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - Eric LeRouge 10:49:26 04/07/03 (2)

Re: MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - MCH 22:46:11 04/08/03 (1)

Cool (nt) - Eric LeRouge 12:03:46 04/09/03 (0)

No "debunk" I'm afraid . . . . . - Martin says 07:35:29 04/07/03 (0)

Cool quote (nt) - Eric LeRouge 02:43:18 04/07/03 (0)

I love your posts. nt - Duilawyer 19:06:25 04/06/03 (0)

Teresa, what do you feel you are accomplishing.. - rick5 17:57:18 04/06/03 (4)

I don't understand your post at all? First all I'm saying is that DVD-Audio could win the war if - Teresa 18:52:41 04/06/03 (3)

Don't say anything for me...you are confusing your - rick5 20:19:22 04/06/03 (1)

sorry I bore you, so even though I listen to high rez PCM recordings, I have to bow down to the - Teresa 22:23:24 04/06/03 (0)

The problem is you are expressing YOUR opinion of which for mat is "better". - oscar 20:12:47 04/06/03 (0)

Follow Ups

So why does soundstage collapse on CD ? - SnaggS 06:54:04 04/07/03 (6)

Not really... - MCH 08:40:58 04/07/03 (4)

Soundstaging -- speakers & CD source . . . - Martin says 02:36:09 04/08/03 (0)

MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - Eric LeRouge 10:49:26 04/07/03 (2)

Re: MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - MCH 22:46:11 04/08/03 (1)

Cool (nt) - Eric LeRouge 12:03:46 04/09/03 (0)

No "debunk" I'm afraid . . . . . - Martin says 07:35:29 04/07/03 (0)