In Reply to: Please prove your claims. posted by EnuffzEnuff on April 6, 2003 at 20:18:34:
In comparisons using Ray Brown's "Soular Energy" DVD-A and SACD, one experienced listener suggested the SACD was like listening to the live event while the DVD-A was like listening to playback of the master tape. The SACD was more relaxing to his ears. OTOH, he thinks vinyl is even more relaxing yet than SACD...Both 24/192 PCM and SACD were very good to my ears and any difference might have been due to differences in source hardware.
Have you played with SACD ? Curious you would want scientific evidence that SACD is "better" ? You've probably already decided LP and tubes are very good despite sometimes atrocious "scientific" "measurements". Your ears are probably telling you something is "right" about LP and tubes, why not SACD ?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Subjective claims cannot really be proven... - oscar 20:45:36 04/06/03 (13)
- Re: Subjective claims cannot really be proven... - Martin says 02:31:32 04/07/03 (12)
- eloquent and absurd - tunenut 10:58:24 04/07/03 (3)
- Eloquent and succinct . . . - Martin says 03:13:08 04/08/03 (1)
- yes I know.. - tunenut 09:36:49 04/08/03 (0)
- agreed go to a live acoustic concert, come home listen to an Audiophile LP on a decent Vinyl rig - Teresa 18:29:57 04/07/03 (0)
- So why does soundstage collapse on CD ? - SnaggS 06:54:04 04/07/03 (6)
- Not really... - MCH 08:40:58 04/07/03 (4)
- Soundstaging -- speakers & CD source . . . - Martin says 02:36:09 04/08/03 (0)
- MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - Eric LeRouge 10:49:26 04/07/03 (2)
- Re: MCH, if I may ask...what are those great speakers? (nt) - MCH 22:46:11 04/08/03 (1)
- Cool (nt) - Eric LeRouge 12:03:46 04/09/03 (0)
- No "debunk" I'm afraid . . . . . - Martin says 07:35:29 04/07/03 (0)
- Cool quote (nt) - Eric LeRouge 02:43:18 04/07/03 (0)