|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
68.117.151.68
In Reply to: RE: Thanks... posted by C.B. on March 24, 2011 at 14:35:38
C.B.,
Your earlier post says “Exception: Klemperer's second version with the old Philharmonia. Great performance, but it's only available on LP--EMI for some strange reason chose to release the first version on CD.”
I read that as saying that the BETTER example of the trumpet/horn balance is found on the 1962, not the 1956.
While I have not knowingly heard the first performance and thus cannot make a comparison, I can say that the ’62 has a very nicely present trumpet voice in that theme statement (and later in the movement, as well).
Additionally, I have to say that I love Klemperer's treatment of the woodwinds generally. This is also apparent in the ’62 Mozart Nº 39.
Yours,
-=- Charlie F.
Follow Ups:
I just checked, and my CD set has the earlier (1956) version, not as good from the standpoint of that trumpet theme as the 1962. The 1962 is just a better all round performance, IMO.
"You weren't afraid of being born--why would you be afraid of dying?" Alan Watts
Thank you!
I was beginning to think that I might need to start looking for the ’56 Klempie – which isn't really on my radar right now. As you said initially, C.B., the’62 recording is very nice. And I appreciate your having pointed out the trumpet balance issue in general. I will be looking for that in my future Classical-period listening.
Yours,
-=- Charlie F.
... is available on Testament:
and it might just be on this set (see link) -
-
"You weren't afraid of being born--why would you be afraid of dying?" Alan Watts
It's the one I included in my first post above: EMI CMS 7 63272 2. I bought it used back in the early ’90s.
And I've really enjoyed focusing on the first movement's brass balance that C.B. first mentioned in this thread.Thanks again.
-=- Charlie F.
I'm almost certain that every time EMI issues Klemperer's #39, it's the stereo (i.e. 1962) version. They licensed the 1956 version, which is monaural, to Testament, because EMI presumably didn't have any interest in issuing it themselves. The 4 CD set that you mention presumably contains 1962, as does the 2CD GROC set, as does this one:
The "Great Recordings of the Century" set I have (EMI 3 45815 2--released 2006) has the 1956 version--as a matter of fact, it even says "first release in stereo" on it! I believe EMI recorded Klemp's early stuff (after 1955 or so) in stereo, but originally released a lot of it on mono LPs only.But thanks for the link! I going to order that version (or maybe the 4-CD set that Charlie has) just to have the 1962 version on CD.
-
"You weren't afraid of being born--why would you be afraid of dying?" Alan Watts
Edits: 03/25/11
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: