In Reply to: HvK Was A Great (uneven) Conductor, period (nt) posted by Severius! on November 27, 2002 at 21:59:07:
Yes, it's just that the unevenness was unacknowledged by himself and far too many others. Still is.And I became bored with people telling me that Karajan was 'the greatest', from the late 1960's onwards.
Fwoop was indeed the problem, just IMO.
BTW Australians are rather more alert to this particular trait and tend to be particulary irrittaed by it. AKA the critique ranges from 'being a bit up himself' through to 'Fwoop', Geddit!
I have a few HVK rcords which I treasure, EMI's Brain Mozart Horn Conc's eg, and Deccas, and some 1960's DGG LvB stuff. I think the DGG box of the Strauss tone poems is excellent - for another example.
I stopped buying HvK quite soon, in the late 1970's, and I can cope with that. Budget went on more Jazz, Popular etc and on choral, and the 18th C and HIP.
Timbo
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: HvK Was A Great (uneven) Conductor, period (nt) - Timbo in Oz 00:37:48 11/28/02 (3)
- Being Australian, how do you feel about Joan Sutherland? - djprobed 07:03:04 11/29/02 (2)
- Re: Being Australian, how do you feel about Joan Sutherland? - Brian Cheney 10:08:26 11/30/02 (0)
- Re: Being Australian, how do you feel about Joan Sutherland? - Timbo in Oz 19:17:10 11/29/02 (0)