Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums

Posted by Chris from Lafayette (A) on July 27, 2017 at 09:11:47

Once again, you have to scroll way down to the bottom to get to the results table. The results are pretty clear - 28 to 9 in favor of separate forums. I'll pass this info on to Rod. And just to summarize what I'm also going to propose: since Classical Court exists already, the classical posters can move there, while the Jazz, World Music, etc posters could stay here on the Music Forum, which would be renamed to Jazz Alley, per hifitommy's original post. Both the Classical Court and Jazz Alley names and links would need to be added to the home page here, as well as to the top of all of the other forums (where all the links are).

One problem is that the past classical discussions would remain here on the Music forum, even after it became Jazz Alley - which doesn't make a lot of sense. I don't know if Rod has an easy way to move these older classical discussions to classical court. Indeed, Rod may want to proceed in a completely different way from what I'm proposing. For instance, he may want to create a separate Jazz Alley forum and leave the existing music forum in place as an area for general discussions about music not connected to any specific genre. In any case, he or I will let you know.

Thank you all for voting and for your interest as we move to our Brave New Worlds! ;-)

YAY - In favor of Separation	NAY - Opposed to Separation
hifitommy	jec01
GEO	kuma
Tweaker456	andy evans
Rick W	musetap
Jim Treanor	Paul_A
Rockethead26	vinyl phanatic
suretyguy	jimbill
mes	dgaapc7
Frihed89	Raiderman
fantja
Dave Pogue
gary.m
pbarach
rlindsa
Jim Pearce
belyin
Mel
bluemooze
csofan
rwa3
HarlemAirShaft
John N
lancelot
ahendler
classfolkphile
dancingseamonkey
rockpassion
Amphissa [changed vote]

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Topic - Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums - Chris from Lafayette 09:11:47 07/27/17 (20)

Sorry I missed the voting, but ... - Feanor 13:21:16 07/29/17 (0)

thankewe RE: Final Vote - hifitommy 16:29:09 07/28/17 (0)

RE: Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums - learsfool 07:00:24 07/28/17 (4)

Absolutely - that's a sine qua non, and there has been discussion about that [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 16:09:45 07/28/17 (3)

RE: Absolutely - that's a sine qua non, and there has been discussion about that [nt] - Tweaker456 13:23:38 07/30/17 (2)

I may get an update later today - I'll let everyone know if I do [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 15:15:24 07/31/17 (1)

RE: I may get an update later today - I'll let everyone know if I do [nt] - fantja 17:50:56 08/05/17 (0)

RE: Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums - ahendler 17:03:04 07/27/17 (2)

It hasn't come back to life yet. . . - Chris from Lafayette 17:28:18 07/27/17 (1)

There's more Classical Court than that - jec01 07:25:55 07/28/17 (0)

RE: Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums - Tweaker456 10:35:49 07/27/17 (9)

So who's going to have the "tunes"? - andy evans 14:37:31 07/27/17 (8)

RE: So who's going to have the "tunes"? - Tweaker456 16:09:48 07/27/17 (0)

Well. you can have the lieder :-) nt - Rick W 15:07:53 07/27/17 (6)

Take Me To Your .... - oldmkvi 15:21:48 07/27/17 (5)

Uh oh. Apparently there's bacteria from the Catskills on your reed. nt - Rick W 16:04:45 07/27/17 (4)

Catskills? Outer Space, Baby! - oldmkvi 16:16:09 07/27/17 (3)

RE: Catskills? Outer Space, Baby! - Tweaker456 23:47:17 07/27/17 (1)

Watch some Crazy Cat cartoons to tune your ear! nt - oldmkvi 00:14:06 07/28/17 (0)

RE: Catskills? Outer Space, Baby! - BubbaMike 17:34:08 07/27/17 (0)

Final Vote on Separate Jazz and Classical Forums

Post a Message!