In Reply to: I agree. But chill. posted by rbolaw on March 12, 2017 at 17:55:22:
The decision to record the Mahler 3rd using the LSO by Solti and then Horenstein would not have been one that was taken by the LSO, IMO. In those days, labels made the decisions about what to record with which orchestras and conductors. Decca had an ongoing Mahler program with Solti, some of which was being done with the LSO, and Unicorn was doing some with Horenstein. There wouldn't have been a GM at the LSO who would have said " Gee, we don't like how the Solti recording turned out, so let's recruit another label and conductor to do this." While I don't know the actual sequence of recording dates, there is a chance that Unicorn would have decided to piggyback on the work done by Decca and Solti to prepare this symphony.
It is a shame the Horenstein did not get to record a complete set of Mahler symphonies in good sound with a good orchestra. He is one of the conductors who link back to Mahler himself, the others being Walter, Klemperer, Mengelberg, and Stowkowski (slightly - he was supposedly present at the premiere of the 8th). Of these, he is the only one other than Mengelberg who had all of the symphonies in his repertoire. Walter, for example, never conducted the 6th - it was overly nihilistic for him, and rarely conducted some of the others, including the 3rd.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Recording decisions - TGR 09:22:17 03/13/17 (16)
- Yes, very true - rbolaw 09:34:44 03/13/17 (15)
- I believe UK Unicorn issued the original Horenstein 3rd. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 09:38:49 03/13/17 (14)
- Correct - TGR 10:25:44 03/13/17 (13)
- Do try the Adler, on Harmonia Mundi. I'll refund your money if you don't like it. ; ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 13:00:10 03/13/17 (12)
- I'll have a listen - rbolaw 18:43:35 03/13/17 (6)
- Please don't encourage him... - Ivan303 19:23:53 03/13/17 (5)
- Did you hear about the new HIP Varese Cycle? - jdaniel@jps.net 20:07:55 03/13/17 (4)
- RE: Varèse - Ivan303 20:23:05 03/13/17 (3)
- His Poem Electronique is one of the most haunting pieces I know - jdaniel@jps.net 21:28:14 03/13/17 (2)
- RE: His Poem Electronique is one of the most haunting pieces I know - oldmkvi 08:01:57 03/15/17 (1)
- RE: His Poem Electronique is one of the most haunting pieces I know - jdaniel@jps.net 08:14:24 03/15/17 (0)
- RE: Do try the Adler, on Harmonia Mundi. I'll refund your money if you don't like it. ; ) nt - TGR 14:37:02 03/13/17 (0)
- FYI, it's on TIDAL so should cost you nothing... - Ivan303 13:26:39 03/13/17 (3)
- Let me know what you think! - jdaniel@jps.net 13:38:24 03/13/17 (0)
- Don't have TIDAL - TGR 13:35:13 03/13/17 (1)
- Close to $20 a month... - Ivan303 17:23:28 03/13/17 (0)