In Reply to: Why Katie Liu did not win the Chopin Competition posted by Chris from Lafayette on October 27, 2015 at 00:38:53:
I was wondering what would have happened if instead of adding up for the total of 17 Juror's marks, the highest and the lowest marks were not considered thus it becomes a total of 15 Jurors. Doing some summing up I get the following marks.
Seong Cho 143-11= 132
CR Hamelin 138-16= 122
Katie Liu Assuming as a best case that Juror TD marks his students equally when each s works out to a maximum of 8 since the total by one Juror cannot exceed 55
128-13= 115
The above clearly shows the first 3 positions.
Now assuming that MA gives KL a maximum of 10, KL's marks works out to
115+(10-4)= 121 < 122
Cheers Chris
Bill
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Why Katie Liu did not win the Chopin Competition - Bill the K 06:47:59 10/29/15 (1)
- Thanks, Bill - yeah, she would have needed help from a couple of other judges too [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 09:49:54 10/29/15 (0)