Indeed, finally a post of yours worthy of a substantial response.

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Stanford -- Stabat Mater - Newey 20:49:07 10/24/15 (84)

Implications of Stanford's Chromaticism - Newey 22:30:11 10/27/15 (21)

"That's what Chris wrote, and he's 100% correct." Wow! - jdaniel@jps.net 09:09:05 10/28/15 (20)

The whole issue with music analysis. . . - Chris from Lafayette 10:02:17 10/28/15 (19)

Illuminating - Newey 21:30:57 10/28/15 (10)

"The old school scholars and critcs (sic) - all of them, to a man - with out a SINGLE EXCEPTION - jdaniel@jps.net 08:47:08 10/29/15 (9)

**WRONG WRONG **DING DONG** WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG - Newey 20:45:49 10/29/15 (8)

"It's staggering to consider that nobody's ever challenged that academic view. EXCEPT ME." - jdaniel@jps.net 21:06:20 10/29/15 (7)

Your Knowledge Of Critical & Academic 20th Cent Trends - Newey 22:40:11 10/29/15 (6)

Sigh. You said, "EXCEPT ME." (Your caps.) Really? Except you? - jdaniel@jps.net 07:48:18 10/30/15 (5)

This Is Like Teaching A Slow Learner - Newey 20:00:26 10/30/15 (1)

Indeed.... - jdaniel@jps.net 07:20:03 10/31/15 (0)

You Sound Just Like A Holocaust Denier - Newey 19:23:49 10/30/15 (2)

This Thread Is No Longer Constructive - Shuting it Down - No Further Posts Coming - Newey 19:49:48 10/30/15 (1)

Could you be a dear and identify this tune for me? I just can't put my finger on it - jdaniel@jps.net 01:10:42 10/31/15 (0)

Coitus Interruptus Dammitus! I forgot about Tristan, the most famous tonic-tease of all time - jdaniel@jps.net 18:44:34 10/28/15 (7)

Nice Move - Newey 21:45:20 10/28/15 (6)

You'd have to know the actual story of Tristan to get the inside joke - jdaniel@jps.net 09:03:44 10/29/15 (5)

You're Right - Newey 20:41:09 10/29/15 (4)

BTW, if you have no time for immorality, how do you tolerate Wagner & Co? When Sieglinde... - jdaniel@jps.net 21:24:03 10/29/15 (3)

RE: BTW, if you have no time for immorality, how do you tolerate Wagner & Co? When Sieglinde... - Newey 22:10:22 10/29/15 (2)

The witticisms are one's only reward, otherwise your posts are pure sophistry, at least when you dare venture - jdaniel@jps.net 06:42:19 10/30/15 (1)

Cut And Paste What????? [nt] - Newey 19:15:06 10/30/15 (0)

Deferring (or even dispensing with) the Tonic is a pretty common, I dare say hackneyed metaphorical trick used - jdaniel@jps.net 18:24:26 10/25/15 (36)

Don't bother. - rbolaw 17:05:21 10/26/15 (21)

There is discussion going on right now about resolving on the tonic! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 01:40:53 10/28/15 (2)

Yes, I was making a funny. nt - rbolaw 11:09:59 10/28/15 (1)

My post was originally a double entendre - but we're taking a wait and see approach now [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 11:50:54 10/28/15 (0)

Applause All Around - Newey 22:37:21 10/27/15 (14)

RE: Applause All Around - rbolaw 10:00:27 10/28/15 (13)

It's cool; I've been riding him a bit hard. And he's right, no composer has ever delayed a tonic to make a - jdaniel@jps.net 19:04:30 10/28/15 (12)

Ha Ha Ha - Best Entertainment - Newey 22:04:52 10/28/15 (11)

"Fruit fly posts" Effeminization of discretion and good taste; let it stand. - jdaniel@jps.net 08:55:48 10/29/15 (8)

**There Is NO *Repeat* NO ad hominem Attack Implied, Intended, or Expressed - Newey 20:34:28 10/29/15 (7)

Then & Now - Is JDaniels The New Rob? - Newey 20:38:55 10/29/15 (2)

What have you said that's correct? - jdaniel@jps.net 21:54:28 10/29/15 (1)

Yep - Super Ultra Correct - Newey 23:19:44 10/29/15 (0)

Fine, just how 'bout less Newey and more Cui from now on? nt - jdaniel@jps.net 20:37:49 10/29/15 (3)

Ceasar Cui? [ nt] - Newey 20:49:45 10/29/15 (2)

Yes, Newey, no one doubts that you know who Cesar Cui is. - jdaniel@jps.net 21:36:39 10/29/15 (1)

The Irony Is - I'm Not "Trying" At All - Newey 19:10:26 10/30/15 (0)

PLEASE try to maintain minimal courtesy, or. . . - Chris from Lafayette 01:17:53 10/29/15 (1)

To The Moderator - Newey 20:27:24 10/29/15 (0)

RE: Don't bother. - jec01 07:47:21 10/27/15 (2)

Don't Be a Hater - Better To Enjoy Music Together [nt] - Newey 21:51:24 10/27/15 (1)

Excellent idea - jec01 06:54:16 10/28/15 (0)

You Have NO Idea What You're Talking About - Newey 21:33:07 10/25/15 (13)

RE: You Have NO Idea What You're Talking About - jazz1 02:17:33 10/26/15 (1)

Friendly - Newey 21:40:21 10/27/15 (0)

Sigh, the piece ends in G Mixolydian; thus what you call the "leading tone" is F, and yes: a whole step from - jdaniel@jps.net 23:09:03 10/25/15 (10)

Finally - Newey 22:23:49 10/27/15 (1)

Indeed, finally a post of yours worthy of a substantial response. - jdaniel@jps.net 05:44:40 10/28/15 (0)

Was just thinking - maybe the OP is hearlng the key of the last movement as C-major. . . - Chris from Lafayette 18:57:19 10/26/15 (2)

As I Look At the Scores and Listen and Think - Newey 22:18:01 10/27/15 (0)

We'll see if any of our detective work... "maters." : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 19:03:20 10/26/15 (0)

You are correct, sir - a very striking ending indeed - Chris from Lafayette 11:40:30 10/26/15 (4)

That's Hot On The Trail - Newey 22:15:43 10/27/15 (0)

Well thank goodness, was listening thru very crappy laptop speakers. - jdaniel@jps.net 18:49:48 10/26/15 (0)

Yes! Stanford had his moments - John Marks 14:27:17 10/26/15 (1)

Hey - there's no more sincere admirer of Stanford's "The Bluebird" than I am [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 16:53:22 10/26/15 (0)

SSI = Social Security Income? Space Studies Institute? Safe Sex Instructor? - Chris from Lafayette 17:32:18 10/25/15 (13)

Society of St. John (Societas Sancti Ioannis) (nt) - riboge 05:19:22 10/26/15 (4)

Excellent (nt) - Newey 21:49:22 10/27/15 (0)

Well, that explains the sexual anxiety. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 18:55:16 10/26/15 (0)

BTW, I'd never run into an SSI before, although I had OSM's and CSC's. . . - Chris from Lafayette 17:11:29 10/26/15 (0)

Darn! - I was hoping it was Safe Sex Instructor - Thanks anyway! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 11:43:22 10/26/15 (0)

RE: SSI = Social Security Income? Space Studies Institute? Safe Sex Instructor? - Newey 22:27:04 10/25/15 (7)

Sounds good to me - I like it when things heat up [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 11:08:08 10/26/15 (6)

RE: Sounds good to me - I like it when things heat up [nt] ;-) - rbolaw 17:07:10 10/26/15 (5)

Why Stir Up Trouble? I'm Contributing Value to this Site - Newey 21:59:25 10/27/15 (0)

Heck, I'd bring back Romy to liven this place up a bit... - Ivan303 18:05:05 10/26/15 (3)

Romy??? I thought his haunt was New England, not Chicago? [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 18:16:23 10/26/15 (2)

No, no, no... - Ivan303 18:39:12 10/26/15 (1)

RE: No, no, no... - rbolaw 19:38:24 10/26/15 (0)

Xenophobic are we? - PAR 16:22:46 10/25/15 (2)

Not That Much - Newey 21:36:17 10/27/15 (0)

And a projectionist too. When choral directors choose boys' voices, they're thinking about clarity, not body parts. - jdaniel@jps.net 17:29:46 10/25/15 (0)

The director of the Tallis Scholars once said... - John Marks 10:56:42 10/25/15 (4)

Of course the Four Weddings and a Funeral spoonerisms.. - John N 13:29:18 10/26/15 (2)

A little-known fact about the recently departed John Marks - John Marks 14:19:59 10/26/15 (1)

Freud Had Something To Say About Those [nt] - Newey 21:43:52 10/27/15 (0)

"favowite" [heh] (nt) - Newey 21:40:09 10/25/15 (0)

I just checked the vocal score over on the IMSLP site - Chris from Lafayette 00:26:01 10/25/15 (2)

RE: Confusing - Travis 09:48:23 10/25/15 (1)

Oops! Sorry for my haste! - Chris from Lafayette 10:30:31 10/25/15 (0)

Follow Ups

Indeed, finally a post of yours worthy of a substantial response. - jdaniel@jps.net 05:44:40 10/28/15 (0)

Post a Message!