In Reply to: Favorite fiths and sixths...crazed NOT crazy! posted by Binayak Bhattacharyya on February 21, 2000 at 10:02:45:
No Binayak, I'm not familiar with the Mengelberg 5th, but I think I found my definite recordings in the Gergievs, whose interpretation of the 6th is a lot alike the one Furtwangler recorded in Cairo 1951. The only thing I like in Mengelberg's recording is the romanticism and of course the great playing of the orchestra, but Gergiev really made me hear some similarities between 'Tristan und Isolde' in the last movement of the 6th and perhaps that's my trigger:-)As you probably know I'm a sucker for Mravinsky when Shostakovich is concerned and although Gergiev's recording of Shostakovich 8 is very good, it just can't compete with Yevgeny's recordings.
Rob
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Favorite fiths and sixths...crazed NOT crazy! - Rob 10:14:26 02/21/00 (4)
- To Gergiev and to receive! - Binayak Bhattacharyya 10:34:49 02/21/00 (3)
- Re: To Gergiev and to receive! - Rob 10:47:49 02/21/00 (2)
- Thanks a million Rob... - Binayak Bhattacharyya 11:02:20 02/21/00 (1)
- You're welcome, have fun! <nt> - Rob 11:13:48 02/21/00 (0)