In Reply to: The best period-instrument Eroica you've never heard... posted by C.B. on March 23, 2011 at 08:56:54:
This is an important and good point, C.B., thanks for bringing it up. Although there were large orchestras before the 2nd half of the 19th century, in general they probably became larger and louder then as concert halls became larger. And larger meant more string instruments, and with steel rather than gut strings. Many wind and brass instruments were redesigned to make them louder, but not nearly enough to compensate.
A major benefit of the HIP movement for orchestral music is the restoration of that balance. Far more important than the use of original instruments (I also agree with you there), or even the degree of vibrato, IMO.
I remember Collegium Aureum, I think I have one or two of their LPs (Haydn, perhaps?), I'll look for more.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- "Ideal balance between strings and winds" - rbolaw 12:33:13 03/23/11 (21)
- Yes, but. . . - Chris from Lafayette 16:29:07 03/23/11 (20)
- interesting optical illusion! (off topic) - rlindsa 05:48:09 03/24/11 (1)
- Far out, man! [nt] :-) - Chris from Lafayette 07:18:40 03/24/11 (0)
- Have you heard Philippe Herreweghe's HIP Bruckner 7th? - rbolaw 05:12:29 03/24/11 (1)
- RE: Have you heard Philippe Herreweghe's HIP Bruckner 7th? - Chris from Lafayette 07:16:59 03/24/11 (0)
- Haven't heard that one... - C.B. 17:51:49 03/23/11 (15)
- CB - please elaborate on this sentence: - jult52 06:29:06 03/24/11 (13)
- RE: CB - please elaborate on this sentence: - C.B. 07:51:06 03/24/11 (12)
- I'd love to read your article - rbolaw 12:46:45 03/25/11 (1)
- Some agreement, some dis- - Charlie F. 15:30:36 03/25/11 (0)
- I have the '62 Klempie/Philharmonia Nº 39 on CD … - Charlie F. 13:15:22 03/24/11 (9)
- Thanks... - C.B. 14:35:38 03/24/11 (8)
- Um, here’s what I read … - Charlie F. 14:52:24 03/24/11 (7)
- I was confused... - C.B. 15:55:26 03/24/11 (6)
- “Confused” is my middle name. - Charlie F. 20:20:42 03/24/11 (5)
- The 1956 Klemperer... - Kas 08:06:06 03/25/11 (4)
- We're looking for the 1962... - C.B. 09:18:02 03/25/11 (3)
- That is “MY” 4-CD set. (:~) - Charlie F. 12:30:20 03/25/11 (0)
- Well, that's easy... - Kas 09:28:05 03/25/11 (1)
- Nope... - C.B. 12:36:19 03/25/11 (0)
- RE: Haven't heard that one... - Chris from Lafayette 18:26:32 03/23/11 (0)