In Reply to: My favorite HIP recording of all time posted by Chris from Lafayette on March 20, 2011 at 14:06:00:
Gawd, I weary of your "no vibrato" tirades. IME, and buying HIP performances since the early 70s, everyone still used vibrato in varying amounts, some very little but always there. Emma Kirkby comes to mind as one who was villified for "no vibrato" when in fact she did use it and still does with discrimination.
You come across as obsessive about this. Tell me why I'm wrong.
"If people don't want to come, nothing will stop them" - Sol Hurok
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: My favorite HIP recording of all time - Travis 16:28:58 03/20/11 (12)
- Yes , he's obsessive, but we love him! - C.B. 18:16:11 03/20/11 (3)
- Guess I'm adding to the beatings. nt - Travis 19:05:32 03/20/11 (2)
- Thanks for bringing it up, though. (nt) - C.B. 05:55:49 03/21/11 (1)
- You are right, C.B., a waste of bandwidth. nt - Travis 10:32:44 03/22/11 (0)
- RE: My favorite HIP recording of all time - Chris from Lafayette 16:36:24 03/20/11 (7)
- RE: My favorite HIP recording of all time - Travis 19:04:26 03/20/11 (6)
- In the interests of preserving peace and harmony. . . - Chris from Lafayette 09:44:11 03/21/11 (4)
- RE: In the interests of preserving peace and harmony. . . - Travis 13:24:04 03/21/11 (3)
- RE: In the interests of preserving peace and harmony. . . - Chris from Lafayette 09:38:46 03/22/11 (2)
- Just a tip. - Travis 10:38:42 03/22/11 (1)
- It's a deal, Travis! I'll lay off the elementary school comparisons for. . . five years? [nt] :-) - Chris from Lafayette 14:36:45 03/22/11 (0)
- Love Emma Kirkby - genungo 06:58:34 03/21/11 (0)