Cable Asylum: REVIEW: Michael Wolff Carbon Ribbon Source Cable by vac

Model:	Carbon Ribbon Source
Category:	Cable
Suggested Retail Price:	$600
Description:	Power Cord for Source Components
Manufacturer URL:	Michael Wolff
Model Picture:	View

Review by vac_man ( A ) on September 27, 2003 at 12:00:04
IP Address: 24.45.1.221

Add Your Review
for the Carbon Ribbon Source

This is a review of the recently released Michael Wolff Carbon Ribbon Source power cord, which uses carbon fiber shielding and some form of carbon ribbon conductors. I am skeptical of power cord claims, but I was attracted to trying out this one because of the extensive use of carbon components. This is a seriously good power cord, at least in my setup described below. I would characterize it, after some 70 hours of break-in, as fast, providing excellent resolution and detail and producing precise images with a focused soundstage. Its most interesting quality, though, is that it just has a very rich harmonic texture that helps my other components to produce a rich, but detailed and balanced sound. In sum, it produces a sound that I would describe as so real that it is â€œspooky.â€
I am not a power cord hound, and I do not have a lot of patience in switching among these components. As a result, I am not one with extensive experience in auditioning power cords. I was curious, though, about how the Carbon Ribbon Source compared with an expensive high-end cord; I recently had this opportunity due to a visit from two audiophile colleagues who brought some different power cords and interconnects to compare. The power cord comparison was with the new Shunyata Anaconda vX power cord, which is a thick, but flexible, cord that rattles (â€œmagic dustâ€?), more like a rattlesnake than an anaconda, when it is moved.
The power cords were used only on the digital front-end, specifically, on an Electrocompaniet EMC-1 UP CD player. The EMC-1 UP feeds a VAC Renaissance Signature Mk II preamplifier through Stealth PGS-3D balanced interconnects, which in turn drives a VAC Renaissance Signature 70/70 amplifier through Stealth PGS-3D single-ended interconnects. The EMC-1 and the VAC pre-amp (and its separate power supply) are placed on a Sistrum SP-5 equipment stand, and the VAC amp sits atop a separate Sistrum SP-101 amp stand. The VAC amp drives a pair of Alon Circe speakers which are on Sistrum SP-004 speaker stands. The Circes are tri-wired with Stealth Ultimate Ribbon speaker cables (silver ribbon) in a custom bi-wire configuration to drive the middle and high frequencies, and with Stealth Premier (litz copper) speaker cables to drive the low frequencies. Needless to say, I am a fan of Sistrum, Stealth and VAC products, but thatâ€™s a different story.
The power is supplied by a 30-amp dedicated line through a Topaz 10 kVA EI-type transformer (a 325 lb beast that sits in my basement) that is hard-wired to provide a balanced 60-0-60 output with a technical ground. This is then fed into a Tice Power Block Signature 3B power conditioner placed on top of a homemade MDF platform that sits on four 1â€ brass cones on the floor. The room is 28â€™ x 21.5â€™ with sloping ceilings in the front and back (no right angle corners); the maximum height is 9â€™ 10â€, and the minimum height is 6â€™ 1â€. The speakers (measured from center of woofer cone) are placed approximately 7â€™ 3â€ apart and approximately 9â€™ 2â€ from the rear wall. Also, two 16â€ ASC tube traps and two homemade (a la Jon Risch) absorption panels are deployed.
So, how did the Anaconda vX and the Carbon Ribbon Source power cords compare? Which is â€œbetterâ€ and why? Well, unfortunately, there is no conclusive answer because it depends on (i) the type of music to which you listen, (ii) your system and (iii) your individual tastes. Both power cords are excellent. They both have a similar speed and ability to handle fast transients. The Anaconda vX appears to have slightly more detail and resolution than the Carbon Ribbon Source. For example, the sound of the piano â€“ a very difficult sound to reproduce accurately â€“ was more accurately reproduced in my system with a very realistic timbre using the Anaconda vX. The piano sounds excellent on the Carbon Ribbon Source, but the Anaconda vX just absolutely nails it. However, once you move away from the piano to vocals, acoustic, jazz or rock â€˜n roll, the Anaconda vX sounded somewhat lean in comparison to the Carbon Ribbon Source.
The Carbon Ribbon Source has a richer harmonic texture, with greater bass extension, than the Anaconda vX, which makes listening to acoustic and vocal pieces as well as dynamic jazz pieces, more enjoyable. For example, on â€œPrologue,â€ the first track of Dave Grusinâ€™s West Side Story (N2K-10021), the very dynamic performance was more musical and more enjoyable on the Carbon Ribbon Source because the soundstage was more coherent and the slightly lesser amount of detail made the overall presentation less edgy. There was plenty of detail and resolution, but the presentation sounded richer, more balanced and more coherent on the Carbon Ribbon Source. I think the Anaconda vX, with its greater detail, may have overemphasized the cymbals and horns and presented a soundstage that was unnaturally wide and somewhat confusing. (This could well be due to the already wide-soundstaging abilities of the EMC-1 UP and the open-baffle-designed Alon Circe speakers.)
I would like to have compared these power cords playing orchestral and choral music, but we spent some of our time spinning LPs and playing around with interconnects, so I cannot tell you how they would have fared. This would be an interesting comparison as it would pit the Anaconda vXâ€™s relative advantage of greater detail and resolution against the Carbon Ribbon Sourceâ€™s relative advantage of richer harmonic texture. All I can tell you is that orchestral and choral music on the Carbon Ribbon Source has a sound that is rich and detailed and with excellent imaging and soundstaging. I sure wish that I had compared this with the Anaconda vX when I had the chance.
It has occurred to me â€“ and this is sheer speculation on my part â€“ that on a higher resolution system, the richer harmonic texture of the Carbon Ribbon Source might outweigh the benefits of the Anaconda; on a lower resolution system, the greater detail and resolution of the Anaconda might outweigh the benefits of the Carbon Ribbon Source. This is so system dependent and taste dependent that it is very hard to make any sort of general statement regarding these two products. Suffice it to say that both the Carbon Ribbon Source and the Anaconda vX were excellent power cords on the Electrocompaniet EMC-1 UP. Each appeared to have a specific relative benefit over the other; itâ€™s more a matter of your tastes and your system as to which you prefer. I preferred the Carbon Ribbon Source on all of the music to which we listened other than piano music.

Product Weakness: Can be used only on source components.
Product Strengths: Fast; rich harmonic texture; and excellent tonal balance with precise imaging and natural soundstage.

Associated Equipment for this Review:
Amplifier:	VAC Renaissance Signature 70/70
Preamplifier (or None if Integrated):	VAC Renaissance SIgnature Mk II
Sources (CDP/Turntable):	Electrocompaniet EMC-1 UP
Speakers:	Alon Circe
Cables/Interconnects:	Stealth PGS-3D XLR (w/ CD player); Stealth PGS-3D RCA (bet. preamp & amp); Stealth Ultimate Ribbon and Premier speaker cables
Music Used (Genre/Selections):	Acoustic, choral, classical, jazz, rock 'n roll
Room Size (LxWxH):	28' x 21.5' x 9'10
Time Period/Length of Audition:	3 weeks
Other (Power Conditioner etc.):	Topaz 10 kVA xfrmr & Tice Power Block 3B Signature
Type of Audition/Review:	Home Audition

Product Weakness:	Can be used only on source components.
Product Strengths:	Fast; rich harmonic texture; and excellent tonal balance with precise imaging and natural soundstage.